x
x
John
likes
X
wine
likes
John
X
x
x
John
likes
X
wine
likes
John
X
likes
Mary
wine
x
likes
John
whom
x
likes
John
whom
X
Y
p
X
Y
q
X
Y
Y
r
Y
X
p
X
q
X
p
X
q
X
uniqueX
X
p
X
q
X
q
X
p
X
q
X